Tracks 1, 2, 4-9, 11, 14-15 recorded from October-November 2004 in a dimly-lit basement with a six-foot ceiling in Springfield, Missouri.

Tracks 3, 10, 18 recorded in November-December 2007 in Lawrence, Kansas.

Tracks 12, 13 recorded at Jabberwocky in Lawrence, Kansas from December 2019-November 2020 with a few interruptions thanks to a certain pandemic.

Track 17 is an archival cassette recording of Johnston and his sister Alyssa singing Christmas songs for their grandparents in 1984. Johnston's parents eventually join in, not realizing they are actually singing for future masses over the Internet, which does not even exist yet. Samples from this cassette and another captured during the creation of this album appear on both versions of "I’ll Be Home for Christmas," “(There’s No Place Like) Home for the Holidays,” as well as "Away in a Manger of Dreams" (which utilizes a sample from a cassette of Johnston interacting with his father at age 2 in 1980).

REVIEW:

"I will see how this week goes, but it is gearing up to be a challenging holiday season, time-wise. Thus, you may find my reviews becoming much more short & sweet; I am going to have a much shorter missive from me to you about this excellent record by artist/writer/singer Chad Thomas Johnston (CTJ as I will now call him). CTJ resides in Lawrence, Kansas, where he day-jobs as a writer, having pieces in many publications you might know such as Spin and In Touch Magazine. Come to find out, he also releases some damn fine Christmas records! Back in 2004, CTJ released a 10-track holiday album, 'All is Calm, All is Bright,' and added tracks to the digital version again in 2005 and 2007. For 2018, CTJ has compiled all of his holiday tracks (all 30 of them) into this beautiful collection, wonderfully titled 'Stalking Stuffers: Coal for the Stocking in Your Soul.' I prefer the secular stuff, as usual, but even the religious material is treated well. It is CTJ’s subtle orchestration choices (the heartbeat in 'Joy to the World') which really made me sit up straight and say 'dammmn, that’s good.' The lo-fi crackling of 'Oh Christmas Tree' was the track that initially got me – it established CTJ as having a certain taste-level that I knew I was going to get into. The record also includes CTJ’s entry into Sufjan Stevens’ Christmas song contest back in 2007, 'Bethlehem (The 51st State).' It is no surprise that CTJ entered this contest, as I feel he and Sufjan would pair well as a Christmas-music double feature. That said, what makes this song fun is that he actually brings Sufjan directly into the song, which is a fantastically fun and interesting approach. In summary, CTJ has promised you coal, but he’s giving you much, much more with 'Stalking Stuffers.'

Bottom Line: RIYL Sufjan Stevens, or if you ARE Sufjan Stevens. This expansive collection of beautifully-orchestrated Christmas songs is wholly worth your time." - Christmas Underground